My standard for untrieds is a little different. If I have worn it on my toes but not my fingers, I consider it untried.
Last week, I did my toes with Rihana and I was bowled over. I remember when that collection came out and I desperately wanted Rihana. I didn't buy then because I was trying to break myself of buying dark shades.
I regretted it right away and more so when my store closed. I was saved by Zoya's great polish exchange.
(It still stings that I'm not getting Zoya's for $2.10 any more but my love is strong and I will pay whatever I must!)